Loss of Sight Due to Delayed Diagnosis

Background

Mrs F consulted a GP in spring 2017 after experiencing a dull, persistent ache in her shoulder joints, hips and both upper legs, which limited her movement.

One month later, she returned to her GP with deteriorating symptoms. By now Mrs F was struggling to get into and out of bed and found it more difficult to climb stairs. She also had a constant ache extending from her forehead across the top of her head, and experienced severe pain in both sides of her jaw when she ate. Her left temple was also sore to touch.

In the month that followed, the vision in Mrs F’s left eye became blurred. She was admitted to hospital after an initial A&E consultation, and approximately four days later, all vision in her left eye had gone.

After being diagnosed with giant cell arteritis (GCA) and polymyalgia rheumatica (PMR), Mrs. F was prescribed high-dose steroid medication and underwent blood transfusions. However, she developed side effects from her medication, such as Cushing’s disease – a condition which:

• Increases the amount of body fat on the chest, tummy and back of the neck
• Allows skin to bruise easily
• Reduces strength in the upper arms and thighs
• Leads to depression and mood swings
• Causes fertility issues
• Can also lead to high blood pressure

The delayed diagnosis claim was pursued by our medical negligence team on the basis that Mrs F’s GP failed to spot PMR during her initial consultation. Because of this failure to diagnose her condition, Mrs F was not prescribed the correct medication, which would have prevented the severe side effects.

Following further investigation, it was also found that negligence by the GP in recognising suggestive symptoms of GCA during her second appointment led to the avoidable loss of sight in Mrs F’s left eye.

Settlement

Initially, the Defendants denied both breach of duty and causation in this eye negligence claim. The claim was eventually settled for £95,000 following exchange of expert evidence, of which £45,000 represented special damages.

This case was led by Tony Mitty.

NOTE: While our case studies are designed to give an indication of the outcomes that can be achieved in these circumstances, the compensation awarded in individual cases can vary significantly due to a range of factors, including effects on life expectancy, the severity of the medical negligence that took place, and the financial impact.